So far I've listed six websites for sale with Flippa, and now after my first auction with them has ended, I'm taking a step back to re-think my opinion of them.
My Opinion of Flippa
I knew Flippa before it was Flippa because it used to be a part of SitePoint - a website about websites. They still have a marketplace, but apparently due to the popularity of their website sales section, they spun off those auctions into a separate site: Flippa.
I'm not totally disappointed with the fact that my first website didn't sell, but I am re-thinking the cost of listing small, inexpensive sites with them. The site I listed is CyberPulpit.com, and while I value the site, I can understand why it didn't fetch the price I'd hoped because it doesn't have a ton of traffic or revenue. I'd hoped to sell it for at least $250, but the bidding only reached $30. With a listing fee of $19, plus a success fee of 5% and a minimum of $5, the least a sale can cost is $24. If I sold the site for $30, I would have taken home $6 - not really even worth the time it took to fill out their forms.
Fine. All that is well and good, caveat emptor, right? However, I'm finding the apparently relentless upsale efforts Flippa uses to try and get sellers to buy more extras - from $5 for a bold listing to $50 for a twitter post. The first offer was fine, but they keep sending these to me, and I've had enough. I even emailed their support staff letting them know that I have many sites to sell, but I'll take my sites elsewhere if they don't stop overselling me.
I was about to list another site with them (Telecom Rebith, a site about the telecommunications industry, cell phones, the internet, and wifi) when I realized that my "trust" with Flippa was reduced from a "9" to an "8" for apparently no reason. I wasn't upset because I'm not really sure that anyone even cares about their trust factors, but it was just enough that I decided there just had to be other website brokers out there and wanted to try one. A quick search turned up WebsiteBroker.com, so I gave it a shot!
My Initial Impression of WebsiteBroker
I only just listed Telecom Rebirth with Website Broker so I can't say too much about them, but there are some obvious differences from Flippa. Here's a quick comparison:
| Flippa | WebsiteBroker |
| Standard Price: | $19 | $9.95 |
| Featured / Premier Price: | $48* | $29.95 |
| Success Fee: | 5% ($5 min, $495 max) | None |
| Listing Length: | 30 days** | 90 days |
* - Flippa has an extra called "featured" that costs $29 on top of the $19 listing fee.
** - Flippa also has private sales that last up to six months.
Naturally most folks like me who like to pinch a penny or five will notice that WebsiteBroker is much cheaper. The higher price would be justified if the broker can sell the site for a higher price, but I'm not sure that Flippa can do that. After a few experiments with other brokerages, I'll find out.
So I've listed Telecom Rebirth and was a little surprised, maybe even impressed, when I learned that WebsiteBroker reviews sites before they are actively listed. This may be the same process that Flippa automates by asking would-be sellers to upload a verification file, but I like the idea that there are some people behind the service.
There are some other differences, too:
- Flippa automates the validation of Google Analytics data, WebsiteBroker asks for login information (yeah right!).
- Flippa apparently allows sellers to bundle sites and domain names in a single auction, WebsiteBroker does not. The WebsiteBroker restriction makes sense to me, and I searched Flippa's site for information about bundling restrictions but couldn't find anything. Maybe that explains their pricing structure?
Oh I just noticed that WebsiteBroker has the ability to automatically verify sites, but its not working for me. At the top of the screen I see this:
Deprecated: Function split() is deprecated in /home/websitebroker/html/verifySite.php on line 29
Uh-oh! Here's a screenshot of the problem:
GoDaddy for Domain Sales
I also happen to own a bunch of potentially valuable domain names and I'm interested in selling those too. Both Flippa and WebsiteBroker allow the selling of domains, but being the frugal SOB that I am I was attracted to GoDaddy's low low prices. To sell a domain through GoDaddy's domain auctions, a one time fee of $4.99 is required to "join" and listings are free (don't you just LOVE that word??).
Listings are only seven days long, and if the domain name sells, GoDaddy gets a 5% cut for sales under $500, and 7% for sales over $500 (though that includes Escrow.com service).
I've joined and am currently trying to sell parti-federaliste.com. While the words are French, the domain has tons of backlinks and a pagerank of five, so I'm hoping it fetches a couple hundred dollars. Its been on the market for about a day and a half with no bids, so I'm starting to wonder if it will get some soon? Aha - actually I just noticed that UrlTrends was getting blocked by my default robots.txt file, so I just unblocked it so that potential buyers can easily get more information about the domain.
If you are interested in buying parti-federaliste.com, you can bid on it here:
Make a Bid to Buy parti-federaliste.com!
Note: One downside to selling with GoDaddy is that they hold payment funds for at least twenty days after a domain has sold.
UPDATE: I'm also using Dynadot to sell a domain and small website, but I'm not going to mention it here because actually I'm not too concerned if it sells there or not.
While the Dynadot marketplace may work for some, I'm not interested in really using it right now because the proceeds from the sale is only issued as Dynadot credits - there is no payout option.
Recent Comments